What we have not settled
A framework that claims to be finished has stopped thinking. These are the questions this version leaves open, and the places where we most want to be argued with.
The architecture
Does contemplative practice deserve its own domain?
It is now held by ETHOS and a cross-domain field. Traditions that treat contemplation as a form of knowledge in its own right (Buddhist, Christian, Sufi, Daoist) may argue it is not reducible to ethics.
Is the ring order the best one?
Kinship is asserted from shared disciplines, not measured. A citation-network or curriculum-overlap study could test which domains are in fact closest.
Are capabilities really transversal?
Transfer of general skills such as critical thinking across domains is contested in learning science. The framework assumes capabilities are cultivated through domains, not in isolation; that assumption needs evidence.
How should the framework be sequenced?
The medieval curriculum had an order of dependence (language before mathematics before philosophy). This framework does not yet say what comes first for a child, an adult in transition or an elder.
Evidence and measurement
Can wisdom be taught, and measured?
Wisdom psychology offers constructs but little evidence that schooling reliably increases wisdom. [41]
What does AI do to human skill over time?
Short-term productivity results are mixed, and long-term effects on skill retention under heavy AI use are largely unmeasured. [45]
How will capability trends continue?
METR reports its measures are becoming harder to interpret as tasks saturate. The framework should be reviewed as new evidence arrives. [43]
Society and economics
Who pays for post-labor education?
A curriculum aimed at flourishing presupposes income, time and institutions that do not yet exist for most people.
What replaces the job as a source of recognition?
Contribution, status and belonging are now largely organised by employment. Alternatives are proposed but untested at scale. [39]
Whose framework is this?
A framework written in English, starting from European history, risks presenting one tradition as universal. It needs authors and reviewers from other traditions.
The project itself
Is the name available?
No organisation by the exact name appeared in a web search (22 November 2026), but humanknowledgeproject.org (registered 2021) and humanknowledgeproject.com (registered 1999) are held by others. Trademark searches have not been done. The name stays provisional.
Spanish edition
The name was chosen to work in English and Spanish ("El Proyecto del Conocimiento Humano"); the site is English-only in this release.
Sources the brief named
The brief listed a Shapiro essay at the slug "techno-feudalism-and-the-neo-bourgeoises"; the page at that address is titled "These Two Things Will DESTROY CAPITALISM" and does not use the term "neo-bourgeoisie". We cite it under its published title.
Contribute
This is version 0.1 of a public draft. Corrections, sources and counter-arguments are welcome as issues on the project repository.